Notguilty...I have never used the walker no shine...but from what I have read from other users it does break down...and is a little messier than st30 or supertape...but as far as shine goes from what I have read it really lives up to it's name...I have been using ST30 just behind the hairline...and as I have said on a previous post..if the hair desnity is somewhat thin...you can see the shine. Cheers