I felt the same way about walker no shine. It seems a little to thick for me for some reason. I would say as far as appearance goes, the blue tape looks the best. It is thinner, and the shine can easily be knocked down by simply rubbing the tape backing onto the tape before u apply to the lace. but the clean up is another story. most find it too messy.

I would say out of the tapes that debbie sells specifically. The super tape would be your next best bet. It seems to be a little thinner then the walker, but again it might have a little shine