Speaking from experience, pulling tape off poly can rip the poly, depending on the brand of tape used.

If you don't mind using two layers of tape, first pu
t down a layer of red tape, and then a layer of your stickier tape on top of it.

To remove, just simply run a hair dryer around the perimeter over the tape. The heat will release the red tape adhesive and both layers will peel right off very easily.

Note that the heat trick doesn't work with the stickier tapes, I have experimented with them without a base layer of red tape, but works like a charm on red tape.