I have tried the Walker's scalp protector with the red lid and its cool, and I've also tried the "Thick" and it is definitely thick, Kind of hard to get it started out of the dabber.. I cant say one is better than the other as I'm still trying to find a method of attachment that I "love" lol... ugh.. Thanks to all of you that chimed in, I know "which tape" is a tired old subject, I'm always hoping in my absence I've missed some awesome new product I've never heard of, sometimes I have!