Get waxworks by paul mitchell. American crew pomade should be ok too.. I have used their grooming cream which is different than the forming cream.. the grooming cream is very high shine and very thick. it gives u a strong hold that isn't crispy,, but its a little strong and greasy for me.. and u can't really mix it with water.. its water resistant.

I think pomade and waxworks is a safe bet. I like the texture of waxworks better and i mix it with water and it gives me a gel type hold, but without the crispy crunchy dry feeling.. it gives me a good shine.. and it has a great lasting power. Lasts me all day. Like gel gets dry after awhile and looks crusty and matted.. waxworks makes me look like i just did my hair all day. its got that clean, shiny look. How u apply it wet or dry will determine how much shine.