color #2 looks about right...I was going to suggest a color #3 from the photo, but if you matched up well to a 2T at the other company, #2 is probably about right for you.(hard to tell by computer screen)
if you are going to just fill in the temple areas, you can make little templates, and cut them out of a stock unit....this will save you money and you can get more than two out of the stock.
DebbieS.