Drew I never tried Propecia, I did use Rogaine for awhile however, my loss started in front and Rogaine does nothing for that. I hid for way to long under a hat as I started wearing a cap when I was about 28. I'm 44 now and all I can tell you if your loss is enough to wear a topper I say a huge go for it. I regret not doing this way sooner. It's so amazing how many years having hair takes off your look. My family all tell me I look like my 20's again. I actually feel younger with this system. So again all I can tell you is go for it! Also I hated looking in the mirror without a hat on, now when I went to store tonight I am looking at myself in windows, car windows and having to do a double take, truly amazed. You won't regret it. Plus all these guys on here are great and will always help you out.