Well u could try sunshine no residue tape see how long of a hold you get on that, it is weaker than the others, so u might not be happy with the hold. Another idea is try that duo tack tape. It is supposed to be red liner on one side and blue tape on the other side, They even sell a thin version of the tape that is very thin. I think u should try this since the red/blue tape worked for u but was too thick, this would solve the "thick" problem